跳至主要内容
圣传真道网CHINA SUFI · 传统文化社区

回复 #1084

作者:

在

#58668
塞外牧人
会员

<p><font size="2">He directly contradicts numerous Ayats and Hadith, which most Muslims know about making Dhikr as a group and its benefits. </font></p><p><strong><font size="2">12。Khalwah (Seclusion) </font></strong></p><p><font size="2">In this segment the author reports that in the Tijaniyya order: </font></p><p><font size="2">"The shaikh is believed to keep each murid’s company constantly, spiritually as well as physically, regardless of number of him murids or their geographical locations. Thus, the Sufi chieftains gradually drag naive Muslims into the impious belief that their shaikhs are omnipresent." </font></p><p><font size="2">Please examine the author’s technique to see if it is a presentation of the truth or a false propaganda against Muslims. He wants us to conclude that Sufi shaykhs "drag naive Muslims into the impious belief that are omnipresent." He starts talking about the Tijanniya order, but ends with condemnations in general terms. He gives no references for this paragraph, and ends with an accusation of omnipresence which his OWN words three lines above do not even substantiate. </font></p><p><font size="2">Next he decides to open a different subject. He says: </font></p><p><font size="2">"Allah says: meaning, "There is no private talk of three, but He is their fourth; nor of five, but He is their sixth; nor of less than that nor of more, but He is with them wheresoever they may be."(58.7) Although it should be accepted in its literal meaning, yet the above verse should not be misconstrued to substantiate the sacreligious and pantheistic belief that Allah the Exalted essentially exists everywhere. Rather, the verse means that Allah, glory be to Him, encompasses everything with His knowledge. " </font></p><p><font size="2">The author says that this verse should be interpreted literally, then goes on to interpret it in the proper way, which is not literal. Then he implies that some, whom the reader is supposed to assume are the Sufis [as he had called their way pantheistic before] interpret this verse literally and calls that pantheism. This claim is false, as the great Sufis have clarified that they do not believe in pantheism, nor do they put limits on Allah swt. In fact the above verse in its improper literal meaning, would limit Allah swt by location and thus has been interpreted in a non-literal way by Ahl al-Sunna [the Sufis and others]. Interestingly the supporters of this author, the Wahhabis are the ones who have limited Allah swt to a place in their interpretation of the verses of Istiwa’ and have expanded on that by translating it into "sitting in person", may Allah(SWT) protect us from this and other heresies. </font></p><p><font size="2">He also says: </font></p><p><font size="2">"The Prophet did not neglect to mention and make clear to his followers any ways or means that lead to success in the Hereafter, nor did he neglect to warn them against any ways or means that lead to misery in the Hereafter. And since the practice of khalwah is not included in the ways and means of success, it must be included in the ways and means of misery. " </font></p><p><font size="2">Again demonstrating logical flaws in his reasoning, the author is first stating that the Prophet, Salla Allahu Alayhi Wa Sallam, was explicit in mentioning any possible way that leads to success or to misery, then he goes on to say that Khalwa was not mentioned in the first group so it must belong to the second group. If his first statement was correct then the Prophet, Salla Allahu Alayhi Wa Sallam, must have clearly warned against Khalwa, which he of course did not do. In fact it is well known that he himself would spend time in seclusion worshipping Allah swt. If he had done this explicitly as he did, and failed to condemn it explicitly, then that is enough evidence that it is permissible. </font></p><p><font size="2">The author frequently makes unreferenced statements in this book as if they are well known facts, here’s an example: </font></p><p><font size="2">"There is also another condition of khalwah: the murid must keep silent throughout the forty days of his khalwah even if he goes out for some reason. Suffice it to know that keeping silent for a whole day is forbidden by the words of the Prophet (s.a.w), "There shall be no keeping silence for a whole day until night."62 Al-Munawee, in his commentary on this hadeeth, says that keeping silent for a whole day is forbidden because it is an imitation of a Christian custom." </font></p><p><font size="2">Just a few paragraphs back the author describing Khalwah stated: "In complete seclusion, the Sufi continously repeats the name of God as a highest form of dthikr." Therefore he himself first denied that the one in khalwah is silent, then stated that he is silent and condemned him. Is this a credible account, or one that is out to condemn Tasawwuf regardless of the facts? The author also tried to prohibit Khalwah by mentioning the Hadith that it is better to mix and be patient with people than to not do so. He is trying to falsely portray a temporary action as a permanent one. He seems to go to any end to try and condemn Tasawwuf. He did not quote a single direct statement from a scholar to support his views regarding Khalwah. </font></p><p><strong><font size="2">13。Al-Kashf (Unveiling) </font></strong></p><p><font size="2">Shaykh Hisham Kabbani wrote in his book _Repudiation of "Salafi" Innovations_ Vol. II (ASFA): </font></p><p><font size="2">Kashf or unveiling consists, according to al-Sharif al-Jurjani’s definition in his Kitab al-ta`rifat, in "apprehending beyond the veil of ordinary phenomena, whether by vision or experience, the meanings and realities that pertain to the unseen. </font></p><p><font size="2">The author of TOSOS states: </font></p><p><font size="2">"It is the ultimate end which the murid looks forward. He tolerates khalwah and succumbs to the will of his shaikh precisely to become one of the people of kashf, who are priviledged with Divine manifestation." </font></p><p><font size="2">This is another of the countless misrepresentations of Tasawwuf in this book. It portrays the Sufi as a power seeker willing to put up with the toils of worship only to reach some special level. Rather the Sufi seeks Allah’s(SWT) pleasure and takes pleasure in worshipping Him. As in the famous Naqshbandi saying, "Allah is my intention and His pleasure is my request" [Allahu Maqsudi wa Ridahu Matlubi]. </font></p><p><font size="2">Now the author states: </font></p><p><font size="2">"There are two points against the Sufi interpretation of kashf and tajalli. First, conceiving metaphysics by kashf is impossible, yet Sufis claim otherwise, contending against the truth. The fact is that whatever exists can be conceived of only within the realm of reason. Once man loses reason, he loses the ability to conceive of anything of its reality, and turns to hallucination and utter nonsense." </font></p><p><font size="2">The author is helpless to try to disprove that Kashf exists, as Imam Ibn Taymiyya[R. whom "Tabari" quotes in a general statement at the begining of the book] himself has said in his book al-Furqan bayna awliya’ al-shaytan wa awliya’ al-rahman(p.52.): </font></p><p><font size="2">"It is established that the awliya’ possess spiritual communications (mukhatabat) and unveilings (mukashafat)." </font></p><p><font size="2">Instead he tries to confuse the issues by : </font></p><p><font size="2">He sets the stage by saying he will show two points not against Kashf, but against the Sufi interpretation of Khasf[and tajalli]. Then he says that "conceiving metaphysics" with Kashf is impossible, but neither does he show that this is an accepted "Sufi interpretation" nor does he show that it is an impossibility, instead stating, "the fact is…", without giving any proof. </font></p><p><font size="2">Introducing a conflict between Kashf and reason where none exists. The author states: "The fact is that whatever exists can be conceived of only within the realm of reason." To conceive here means, "to form a mental image" while kashf means "an unveiling" and is not an active act on the part of the recipient. Therefore we are not talking about forming images in ones mind using reasoning ability, rather being shown[or hearing etc.] something that others do not perceive. This has nothing to do with reasoning. </font></p><p><font size="2">Then the author continues… "Secondly, any claim that the Divine essence can appear, whether in existence or beyond it, … … … [etc. etc. etc.]" </font></p><p><font size="2">Again he is trying to disprove something which no one has denied in the first place, i.e. no one has claimed that "the Divine essence can appear". Rather his line of arguing suggests that he has a gross misperception of what Tasawwuf is or is trying to force foreign ideas of his own imagination onto Tasawwuf. </font></p><p><font size="2">He continues by slandering a controversial figure in Tasawwuf, Abu Mansoor al-Hallaj presenting him without mentioning that he was opposed by some Sufis while vindicated by some scholars. The author chooses to join those opposing him and to slander all of Tasawwuf as well. Then he slanders Abdul-Karim al-Jili, quoting for him one quote from Nasrollah Fatemi[not a ‘scholar of Islam’]: </font></p><p><font size="2">"He further asserted in his book that the Prophet Muhammad (s.a.w) is the perfect man and the perfect god. From these blasphemous theories, el-Jili went on to declare himself to be a god also, and exclaimed, "To me belongs sovereignty in both worlds." </font></p><p><font size="2">Can this author stand in an Islamic trial and claim that Shaykh Abdul-Karim al-Jili claimed to be ‘a god’ and that our Prophet, Salla Allahu Alayhi Wa Sallam, is "the perfect god", based on some translation written by a man not known for his expertise in this field?; absolutely not, neither can he find an authentic Sufi who will say that, as it is an unjust lie against Sufis. He finishes this chapter by implying an accusation of Kufr on the above mentioned author, inspite of the useless evidence he presents: </font></p><p><font size="2">"This assertion is blatant enough to condemn anyone who utters it of clear kufr, or disbelief." </font></p><p><font size="2">Then he confirms his implication[again inspite of a lack of solid references] : </font></p><p><font size="2">"Whenever such zindiqs, or heretics are mentioned, Sufis live up to their beliefs by invoking Allah’s mercy on them, unaware of the fact that tolerance of kufr is itself an act of kufr, and that whoever invokes Allah’s mercy on an unbeliever commits a grave sin." </font></p><p><font size="2">This sentence is in fact accusing thousands of Ahl al-Sunna["Sufis"] of Kufr[i.e. the beliefs he said show clear kufr earlier but failed to prove that anyone has supported these words]. </font></p><p><strong><font size="2">14。Al-Fanaa’ (Annihilation) </font></strong></p><p><font size="2">Simply the annihilation of one’s desires and whims, instead following only what pleases Allah(SWT). </font></p><p><font size="2">In this chapter "AA Tabari" says: </font></p><p><font size="2">"Like most Sufi tenets, fanaa’ is mentioned neither in the Qur’an nor in the Sunnah. It is rather a Sufi gimmick and a satanic deception, originally schemed by mystics among the Jews, Zoroastrians and Christians to adulterate the great religion of Islam.(70)" [note ref.70 is Sh. al-Djaza’iri, the contemporary Salafi] </font></p><p><font size="2">The meanings reflected in "annihilation" are replete in the Quran, the Sunna and the explanations of the scholars. An example is in the Quran 79:40,41[trans.] </font></p><p><font size="2">"And he who fears his Lord’s station and prevented his self from lusts then the Garden is recompense". </font></p><p><font size="2">The word itself is used in relation to the everlastingness of Allah swt versus the transience of all else in the Quran, 55:26,27[trans.] </font></p><p><font size="2">"All upon it is annihilated and there remains the Countenance of your Lord of Majesty and Graciousness." </font></p><p><font size="2">"AA Tabari" writes: </font></p><p><font size="2">"To give a better idea of the Sufi concept of Allah, Qunawi, one of Ibn Arabi’s disciples, writes: </font></p><p><font size="2">…But the end of love is unity. In the last analysis, God and the perfect man are one, for Being is one."(69)" </font></p><p><font size="2">Reference 69 is "Fakhruddin Iraqi, Divine Flashes, p.24" however when I found this book in the library, I found the above quote on page 26, and it was NOT by Sh. Qunawi, it was by the orientalist translators of the book, WILLIAM C. Chittick and PETER Lamborn Wilson in their introduction(!!!), following a quote attributed to Sh. Qunawi. Again we see "AA Tabari" relies on information which is translated by orientalists, MISQUOTES it and bases on this a declaration that Sufis are heretics. </font></p>
[此贴子已经被东方宏道于2007-2-7 10:29:29编辑过]